← Aladdin the Musical on Broadway · back to the Broadway Carpet Ride guide

The house

The 1903 Broadway house on 42nd Street, and how Disney brought it back

A Beaux-Arts theatre built in 1903, a movie house, a ruin and a Disney restoration finished in 1997: the history of the building that now hosts Aladdin.

By Broadway Carpet Ride Guide · facts last checked

Find my night ↗

Quick answer

The theatre that stages Aladdin is the New Amsterdam Theatre on West 42nd Street, built in 1902 and 1903 to a design by Herts and Tallant and opened on 26 October 1903. It became a cinema in 1937, fell into disrepair, and was restored for Disney in a project that Wikipedia says was completed on 2 April 1997. Aladdin began previews there in February 2014 and opened in March.

Built for Klaw and Erlanger

A tall brick and stone building on a city street in an early photograph, with signs along its upper storeys
The theatre's 42nd Street frontage in 1905, two years after it opened. · Photo: Detroit Publishing Company, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The New Amsterdam was developed from 1902 to 1903 for the producers Klaw and Erlanger, who operated it for more than two decades after it opened on 26 October 1903. It was designed by the architects Herts and Tallant. Wikipedia describes a Beaux-Arts exterior with Art Nouveau elements, and an interior in the same spirit, and records that the theatre was named for the Dutch settlement of New Amsterdam, the forerunner of New York City. It opened with A Midsummer Night's Dream, which was a failure despite costing five times as much as a typical Broadway show. The building was also a technical showpiece for its date, with a steel frame, fireproofing and heating, cooling and vacuum-cleaning systems.

The Follies, the cinema and the long decline

An ornamental stone doorway with carved figures and an arched window, in an early photograph
The theatre's entrance, as photographed for a 1904 publication. · Photo: Hall, for Herts & Tallant, architects, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

From 1913 to 1927 the theatre was home to the Ziegfeld Follies, whose producer kept an office in the building and ran a rooftop theatre there. In 1937 it was sold on condition that it never host burlesque, renovated with a marquee in place of the original decoration and used as a cinema, which it remained until 1983. A restoration planned by the Nederlander Organization stalled partway through; the roof leaked and the interior suffered water damage. By the early 1990s the state agency that owned it had to stabilise a structure where plaster had fallen and mushrooms were growing through the auditorium floor. The theatre was, in other words, a ruin in the middle of a district that was itself being cleaned up.

Disney's restoration

Wikipedia dates the turn to 1993, when Disney's chairman toured the building and agreed to renovate it. In February 1994 Disney promised $8 million of its own equity plus a loan from the city and state, and in May 1995 Disney Theatrical Productions signed a 49-year lease. The design firm Hardy Holzman Pfeiffer was hired for the work, and Walt Disney Imagineering oversaw it. Conservators took a paint sample from a billboard outside and found 121 layers of paint, each for a different event. The project recreated about half the oak panelling and three-quarters of the plaster decoration and added new mechanical systems. Wikipedia records the restoration as finished on 2 April 1997.

From King David to Aladdin

The first production after the restoration was a limited engagement of a concert version of King David in May 1997, followed by the premiere of the film Hercules. Disney chose those events so the theatre would not be overshadowed by The Lion King, which opened there in November 1997. That show stayed until 2006 and gave way to Mary Poppins, which ran until 2013. Aladdin began previews on 26 February 2014 and opened on 20 March. Wikipedia adds that the restoration helped spur the redevelopment of Times Square, and that it led some observers to complain about the district's Disneyfication, a charge made by people who were unaware of Disney's investment in the building.

What it means on the night

The history is useful because it changes what you see. A visitor who walks in knowing the building was a ruin in the early 1990s will read the gilded details, the decorative plaster and the proscenium differently. Wikipedia mentions peacock figures in dark green on the proscenium, floral motifs and female figures around the dome, and an auditorium with a domed ceiling and two balconies over the orchestra level. The theatre is a New York City landmark inside and out and sits on the National Register of Historic Places, so the decoration is part of the evening, not a backdrop. Arrive a little early to take it in.

Frequently asked questions

When did the theatre open?

Wikipedia gives 26 October 1903 for the opening, with Herts and Tallant as architects.

When did Disney finish restoring it?

Wikipedia records the restoration as finished on 2 April 1997.

Find my night ↗

Sources

  1. Wikipedia: New Amsterdam Theatre
  2. Wikipedia: 42nd Street (Manhattan)
  3. Wikipedia: Times Square
  4. Wikipedia: Aladdin (2011 musical)
  5. Wikipedia: Broadway theatre

More things to do nearby

Find my nightSecure checkout · No hidden fees